Inspired-Training
Experience or stupidity may get you there...
 only
inspired training will get you back!

HOME                     DecoChek-Help File

DecoChek- Popular Software Analysis


DecoChek-DIVE ANALYSER

A profile for 80 metres for 25 minutes...whose software is right?

         Decompression Printout                                      Deco Stops Analysis

 

DecoPlanner from GUE uses a Buhlmann algorithm with Gradient Factor method overlapped.
In This example the GF lo factor is 30 and GF Hi is 80
These are popular parameters, better suited to nitrogen/oxygen dives
A better combination for trimix would be GF lo 20 and High 65.
The immmediate descent function is in use making the overall length of the decompression acceptable.
GF hi should be lowered to 75 to lengthen the shallower stops in this example

Decoplanner analysis

GAP software again uses a Buhlmann style algorithm with Gradient Factor overlay.
The Gradient Factors are set Lo 30 Hi 80
Analysis of this profile shows a shallower first stop than before, possibly a little too shallow
The ascent ceiling is followed more closely than Decoplanner.
The time spent in the shallows, borders insufficient.
By dropping the GF High with this program to 60, a more conservative approach can be followed
This program should be used with high conservatism values, or damage to slow tissues is possible. Pocket PC version gives more conservative results

GAP analysis

Abysmal Products (ironic) uses a proprietary set of values. This example uses the Abyss 120 algorithm to give this typical Bend and Mend schedule. The fast tissue stops  are too short. Stop time increases dramatically to undo the earlier damage. This method only sometimes works. A Heads or Tails decompression outcome is likely! Expect to feel tired (at least) after this schedule.

Abyss analysis

Older version of Proplanner (pre 2min deep stops) uses Buhlmann style values modified with Pyle deep stop method. This gives acceptable ascent schedule for this depth/time. The program is user friendly and usefully conservative. The decompression analysis gives no warnings at all.

proplanner analysis

VR3 dive computer in plan mode. This computer inserts mandatory 2 minute deep stops at Pyle stop depths. This method adds conservatism, compared with earlier releases of Proplanner. The extra time in deep water does however trigger a counter diffusion warning at gas switch. A concern for open circuit divers also closed circuit divers switching to bail out. Add helium here or increase pre switch stop time or reduce bottom time.

VR3 analysis

Zplanner has been  withdrawn from circulation, but has a wide user base. The deeper stops are still ongassing the diver with little redress in the shallows This profile  shows a typical Bend and Mend schedule. The software interface is very easy to use.

zplanner analysis

Another Abysmal diving product. RGBM algorithm in use. This method gives a plethora of deep stops, most in the on gassing range. Slow tissues are poorly taken care of. Type 1 decompression sickness highly likely.

Abyss RGBM analysis

VPM algorithm in use. VPMb with nominal conservatism gives very similar results to RGBM above This method gives a rake of deep stops, most in the on gassing range. Slow tissues are poorly taken care of. Type 1 decompression sickness highly likely.

VPMb nominal conserv  analysis

VPM algorithm in use. VPMb with level 4 conservatism adds only small amount of conservatism compared to nominal level This method gives a plethora of deep stops, many  in the medium/slow tissue on gassing range. Slow tissues are poorly taken care of. Type 1 decompression sickness highly likely unless shallow stops are lengthened

VPMb +4conserv analysis

Gap RGBM. Gives ascent times very similar to VPMb and Abyss RGBM, but as you will see is the most aggressive with shortest time to surface. Repetitive dives using this plan is highly likely to give undesirable results.

 Pocket PC version more conservative

GAP RGBM analysis
 

 

As you can see, the profile of 80metres for 25 minutes gives many different ascent schedules. Using the DecoChek Analysis software, will give you a heads up to the possible outcome. The Decompression analyser allows you to add time in the shallows or adapt decompression gases and bail out choices instantly.

Software Decompression tables may give acceptable schedules for certain depth ranges, but be unsafe in others...below 90metres / 20 minutes is a wilderness!

Decompression is a complex science...even if the numbers look right, many physiological processes can affect its predictability, but...

Information is one of the keys to the door of success

(ancient proverb circa 1990 anon 2nd hand car salesman)

 

 

Have fun…dive safe…dive educated

HOME

copyright Mark Ellyatt
mark@inspired-training